The span between this show at Merriweather and my last show before that at Coventry is five years to the day. The night before Merriweather they put together at Hampton an incredible setlist on paper and, as I’m told, in person. I got pavilion seats through the lottery, right next to the tapers and the sound booth, so the sound was guaranteed to be more or less the best in the venue. I have been listening to shows occasionally during the tour and they’ve been playing extremely well, especially Page. They walked on the stage and the place erupted, with my help. I used to love that band, and here they were, about to melt my face again.
After some discussion on stage, apparently initiated by Trey, they opened with “Crowd Control,” a song off Undermind. He may have been alluding to the fact that the place was overly crowded, which it most certainly was, but Crowd Control is a remarkably shitty choice for the first song nonetheless, and a rather subpar song to begin with. They redeemed the second song choice – Kill Devil Falls – with the third – Sloth- before gracelessly tripping into Beauty of a Broken Heart.
At this point, I considered: “Maybe I don’t like Phish anymore.” Sloth was good and Kill Devil Falls has a lot of potential, but there was nothing saving the opening of that set. As it went on though, I realized that it wasn’t the playing that night at all; the song selection was fucking atrocious. Everything was either brand-spankin’ new or old and rare, and not much in between. Check it:
Set I: Crowd Control, Kill Devil Falls, Sloth, Beauty of a Broken Heart, Axilla I, Foam, Esther, Ha Ha Ha, Party Time, Tube, Stealing Time from the Faulty Plan, Strange Design, Time Turns Elastic
Set II: Tweezer > Taste, Alaska, Let Me Lie, 46 Days, Oh! Sweet Nuthin’, Harry Hood
E: Good Times Bad Times, Tweezer Reprise
They fell into a couple of noticeable grooves that reminded me of why I started seeing Phish in the first place: Axilla I was on fire, Esther and Ha Ha Ha were appreciated by the old heads, Party Time is a new and mighty fun one that will see a lot of playing time, and Trey played Tube because that’s what he thought people were saying. Oh! Sweet Nuthin’ is a gorgeous song, as is Strange Design, an absolute fucking gem. And the crowd loved Good Times Bad Times.
But the song selection kept them from finding that steady current that carries a good show from open to close. Alaska is a solid song, but following it with Let Me Lie is simply not the right decision. Strange Design should have ended set I, not Time Turns Elastic, which just sent everyone into the bathrooms early and into the setbreak wondering why they were playing so many new ones. Set II started and ended well, but the momentum was completely lost in the middle.
I dwell on the song selection because it really is the only downside of this show . Each member of Phish is playing phenomenally, given the time apart from each other and the intense pressure of coming back to a phantatic crowd (yes, I did that) and, most importantly, they’re having fun. A Phish show is often spectacular, sometimes mediocre, rarely regrettable. I will continue to see this band for as long as they play together, just like last time.